
manganese dendrite
Mohs 3–4
rock · common
Also called dendrite, dendrites, fern fossil lookalike, moss fossil, pyrolusite dendrite.
Fossil or pseudofossil?
Manganese dendrites branch along cracks with no stem or veins, concretions are stone right to the center, and weathering makes shapes that only look like animals. Real fossils repeat the same anatomy in order: a fern’s stem and leaflets, an egg’s thin shell, a trilobite’s segments.
Tap a find to compare the fake with the real one. Tap a number to see the clue.

These black “ferns” grow across a slab of sandstone. What are they?
Fake: manganese dendrites
These look like little plants, but they are a dark mineral that crept along a crack. They branch every which way and have no stem or veins.
- Made of
- Manganese oxide minerals
- Grows
- Along cracks and bedding planes, from the edge inward
- Real or fake
- Fake: a pseudofossil
How we know
The Geological Survey of Western Australia describes dendrites as branching crystal growths, usually manganese oxide minerals, that grow along cracks and look darker than the rock around them. It gives two tests: plant fossils lie flat on bedding surfaces while dendrites can extend in three dimensions and cross the bedding, and dendrite patterns are more irregular than leaves.
The photographer, geologist James St. John, calls manganese dendrites classic pseudofossils: structures that resemble fossils but are definitely not. They form, he writes, as fluids seep along bedding planes or fractures and leave manganese oxide behind.
Sources, checked November 2026: Geological Survey of Western Australia: Pseudofossils; James St. John, photo notes on Wikimedia Commons.Real: a fossil seed fern from Illinois
This is a real plant fossil. A stem runs down the middle, and the same leaflet shape repeats on both sides, each with its own vein.
- Plant
- Alethopteris, a seed fern
- Age
- Middle Pennsylvanian, a coal-swamp forest
- This piece
- Mazon Creek area, Illinois, split open from an ironstone concretion
How we know
Repeated, ordered anatomy is the strongest sign of a real fossil. Here it is a central stem with matching leaflets, each with its own midvein, the regular pattern the Geological Survey of Western Australia says dendrites lack.
James St. John identifies this as Alethopteris, the foliage of a seed fern: a tree-like plant with fern-like fronds that reproduced by seeds, not a true fern. It comes from the Mazon Creek fossil beds of northern Illinois, where the Francis Creek Shale holds ironstone concretions that, in his words, can be fossiliferous or nonfossiliferous.
That is the twist in this lesson. A concretion is not a fossil, but it can hold one: the Western Australian survey notes that concretions can form around a shell or a leaf, and cracking one open can reveal the fossil inside.
Sources, checked November 2026: James St. John, photo notes on Wikimedia Commons; Geological Survey of Western Australia: Pseudofossils.Fake: a concretion shaped like an egg
This egg in the desert is a concretion, a lump of hardened sand. Break one and it is stone all the way through, often in rings, with no shell.
- Made of
- Sediment cemented by minerals, often in layers
- Where
- Bayanzag, Gobi Desert, Mongolia
- Real or fake
- Fake: a pseudofossil
How we know
The Geological Survey of Western Australia explains that concretions form as minerals precipitate in layers around a central nucleus while water moves through sediment. They are typically round with distinct internal layering, and it says they are often mistaken for eggs, marbles or bowling balls.
The photographer, Yanish E, labeled this one a “dinosaur egg” concretion found in what the photo’s caption calls the Dinosaur Valley of Bayanzag in Mongolia’s Gobi Desert. The name shows how easily an egg-shaped stone gets taken for an egg.
Sources, checked November 2026: Geological Survey of Western Australia: Pseudofossils; Yanish E, photo on Wikimedia Commons.Real: fossil eggs with their shells
Real fossil eggs have a thin shell, and the shell cracks into a mosaic of little plates. Under a microscope it shows tiny pores that let the baby breathe.
- Shell
- A thin layer of calcite with pore canals
- Clue you can see
- Shell cracked into a mosaic of plates
- These eggs
- On display at the Kunming City Museum, China
How we know
The University of California Museum of Paleontology explains that most egg-laying reptiles and birds build eggshell from calcite (turtles use aragonite), with pore canals running through the shell for gas exchange. Paleontologists describe fossil eggs by shape, size, shell thickness, pore pattern and the texture of the outer shell.
The same museum notes that the only way to know for sure who laid an egg is to find an embryo inside. Most fossil eggshell is identified by its microscopic structure, so a museum or university, not a photo, settles a possible egg.
These eggs, photographed by Gary Todd in the Kunming City Museum in Yunnan, China, are labeled as dinosaur eggs. Their shells show the cracked-plate mosaic that a concretion’s surface does not have.
Sources, checked November 2026: University of California Museum of Paleontology: Fossil eggshell, introduction; UCMP: Eggshell morphology and structure; UCMP: Eggshell identification; Gary Todd, photo on Wikimedia Commons.Fake: a weathered pebble shaped like a trilobite
A student asked if this was a trilobite. It is a siltstone pebble whose soft layers wore away faster than the hard ones.
- Made by
- Differential weathering: soft parts wear away first
- Real or fake
- Fake: a pseudofossil
- This piece
- A gravel bar on the Licking River, Ohio
How we know
James St. John, who photographed this pebble, explains that soft parts of a rock weather and erode faster than hard parts, so one stone can wear unevenly into odd shapes. He writes that this siltstone looks a bit like a fossil, that one of his students asked if it was a trilobite, and that it is a pseudotrilobite.
The Geological Survey of Western Australia makes the general point: wind, water and time shape rocks into forms that look like past life, and these pseudofossils are formed by non-living processes.
Sources, checked November 2026: James St. John, photo notes on Wikimedia Commons; Geological Survey of Western Australia: Pseudofossils.Real: a trilobite from Utah
A real trilobite has a head, a body made of many matching segments and a tail. Its body is split into three lobes down its length.
- Animal
- Elrathia kingii, an extinct sea animal
- Age
- Middle Cambrian
- This piece
- House Range, western Utah, rock 3.4 cm across
How we know
James St. John describes trilobites as extinct sea arthropods with a skeleton in three parts both ways: across, a middle lobe and two side lobes; and lengthwise, a head (cephalon), a body of many segments (thorax) and a tail (pygidium). What fossilizes is the hard calcite exoskeleton.
He calls Elrathia kingii, from the Wheeler Formation of Utah’s House Range, one of the most abundantly preserved trilobites on Earth.
This is the test for any “bug rock”: a fossil repeats the same parts in the same order, and the pattern matches a known animal. Weathering makes grooves and ridges, but not matching segments, eyes and a tail.
Sources, checked November 2026: James St. John, photo notes on Wikimedia Commons.You crack open a round, egg-shaped stone and it is solid rock in rings all the way to the middle. What is it?
How to identify manganese dendrite
Drag it across the back of a ceramic tile. Manganese dendrite leaves a white or no streak.
A copper coin (3.5) marks it faintly. A steel blade (5.5) scratches it easily, and it will not scratch glass.
A drop of vinegar on a fresh surface fizzes strongly. Manganese dendrite is a carbonate; the acid releases carbon dioxide.
Manganese dendrite does not fluoresce under UV.
A drawing made from its color and luster.
Send photos so we can scan one →How hard is manganese dendrite?
Manganese dendrite is 3 to 4 on the Mohs scale. A copper coin (3.5) marks it faintly. A steel blade (5.5) scratches it easily, and it will not scratch glass.
Mohs scale from 1, talc, to 10, diamond. A fingernail is 2.5, a copper coin 3.5, a steel knife 5.5 and a steel file 6.5.
- Mohs hardness
- 3–4A copper coin marks it faintly; a steel blade scratches it easily.
- Streak
- white
- Color
- blackwhitetantwo colors
- Luster
- dull
- Light
- opaque
- Habit
- dendritic
- Fracture
- uneven
- In vinegar
- Fizzes stronglyVinegar or dilute hydrochloric acid.
- Magnetic
- No
Stones mistaken for manganese dendrite
ShungiteBlack, hardness 3.5–4.Manganese dendrite fizzes in vinegar; Shungite does not.black shaleBlack or gray, hardness 1.5–3.Manganese dendrite fizzes in vinegar; black shale does not.coalBlack, hardness 2–2.5.Manganese dendrite fizzes in vinegar; coal does not.
bituminous coalBlack, hardness 2–2.5.Manganese dendrite fizzes in vinegar; bituminous coal does not.How hard is manganese dendrite?
Manganese dendrite has a Mohs hardness of 3–4. A copper coin (3.5) marks it faintly. A steel blade (5.5) scratches it easily, and it will not scratch glass.
What color is the streak of manganese dendrite?
Manganese dendrite leaves a white streak on an unglazed ceramic tile. The streak is the color of the powder and is more reliable than the color of the surface.
Does manganese dendrite react with vinegar?
A drop of vinegar on a fresh surface fizzes strongly. Manganese dendrite is a carbonate; the acid releases carbon dioxide.
What is manganese dendrite confused with?
Shungite, black shale, coal and bituminous coal. Manganese dendrite fizzes in vinegar; Shungite does not.
Photographs of manganese dendrite

We have no 3D scan of manganese dendrite yet. If you own a good piece, send phone photos and we will build one, credited to you.
Photo credits, Wikimedia Commons: Bituminous coal by Nessa Eull, CC0.




